Facebook LinkedIn Twitter

IAEE Members and subscribers to The Energy Journal: Please log in to access the full text article or receive discounted pricing for this article.

Economic Inefficiencies of Cost-based Electricity Market Designs

Some restructured power systems rely on audited cost information instead of competitive bids for the dispatch and pricing of electricity in real time, particularly in hydro systems in Latin America. Audited costs are also substituted for bids in U.S. markets when local market power is demonstrated to be present. Regulators that favor a cost-based design argue that this is more appropriate for systems with a small number of generation firms because it eliminates the possibilities for generators to behave strategically in the spot market, which is a main concern in bid-based markets. We discuss existing results on market power issues in cost- and bid-based designs and present a counterintuitive example, in which forcing spot prices to be equal to marginal costs in a concentrated market can actually yield lower social welfare than under a bid-based market design due to perverse investment incentives. Additionally, we discuss the difficulty of auditing the true opportunity costs of generators in cost-based markets and how this can lead to distorted dispatch schedules and prices, ultimately affecting the long-term economic efficiency of a system. An important example is opportunity costs that diverge from direct fuel costs due to energy or start limits, or other generator constraints. Most of these arise because of physical and financial inflexibilities that become more relevant with increasing shares of variable and unpredictable generation from renewables.

Download Executive Summary Purchase ( $25 )

Download Appendix 

Energy Specializations: Electricity – Markets and Prices ; Energy Modeling – Sectoral Energy Demand & Technology; Energy Modeling – Forecasting and Market Analysis

JEL Codes:
D42 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design: Monopoly
Q55 - Environmental Economics: Technological Innovation
D4 -

Keywords: Electricity market design, market power, equilibrium modeling, opportunity costs

DOI: 10.5547/01956574.39.3.fmun

References: Reference information is available for this article. Join IAEE, log in, or purchase the article to view reference data.

Published in Volume 39, Number 3 of The Quarterly Journal of the IAEE's Energy Economics Education Foundation.